ENI Action Figures Comics Games Horror Marvel Star Wars Transformers  
Animation Anime ARCADE Classifieds Entertainment Television Podcasts


Review: Transformers: Last Stand of the Wreckers #5

Review: Ender
Date: May 20, 2010
Rating:

Sometimes a comic lets you down. Sometimes Transformers stories start out great… and then lose their way. Sometimes, no matter how much you wanted to like a series, it just doesn’t live up to its promise.

Other times, things rock so hard they threaten bladder control and you’re forced to seek counseling after reading them because you realize that it is unlikely anything you read will ever rock quite so hard, ever again.

Last Stand of the Wreckers #5 and the series it concludes, are in the latter category. (The Doctors say I’ll make a full recovery.)

Issue 5 brings us to the titular “Last Stand” of Last Stand of the Wreckers. It’s a stunning ending that solidifies Wreckers place as (arguably) the new apex of Transformers fiction. The body count doubles, mechfluid flies, and the tragedy unfolds.

It’s not a comic for kids. Not just because of the graphic nature of the violence, but because the emotional subtlety of the story would be lost on most of the under 13 crowd. (Note: I’m sure many kids out there are advanced enough to enjoy the book properly, I merely suggest parents use judgment, lest they find them selves in need of a therapist and/or rubber sheets.)

Every page turn brings another shock, revelation, or gut wrenching assault. It’s not entertaining because its fun. It’s engaging because it’s visceral. It’s compelling because it rings true. This is a complexity of story that Transformers fiction has rarely, if ever, even touched, much less explored. From the first panel on, the whole issue carries this horrible feeling of inevitability one can only normally experience by falling off of a cliff.

Death looms around every page, and you’ll be surprised to see who survives. There is an emotional truth to this ending. Sublime Pathos mixed with the futility of violent conflict. That’s what distinguishes Last Stand in the annals of Transformers media, its depth. This is quality writing, the kind people win awards for.

As always in Wreckers the dialog is amazing. They even worked in some text from The Charge of the Light Brigade and, if I’m not mistaken, a line from Red Dwarf. It’s a rare and gifted writing team that can find room for both Tennyson and Grant/Naylor in one comic.

The characters, most second stringers, who had little more that a name, a blurb, and a quote 5 issues ago, are now like old friends. Most top shelf Transformers have less character after 25+ years in the lime light. With out that believability of character even a story this rich would fall apart.

Roche and Roberts achievement here is simply stunning.

Frankly it’s better than we have any right to expect from a comic deriving from a toy license. This is the Transformers answer to Watchmen.

The art this issue provided solely once again by Mr. Roche, with colors by Josh Burcham, is amazing. The past few months of Transformers comics have shown us that there are many ways to bring G1 Transformers to the page, some great, some not so much, Nick Roche gets it right. It’s cartoonish with out lacking detail. Expressive faces, even mouth-less ones, that conduct such accessible emotions and define personality so well, you might not even notice how distinct they are.

More goes on in one Roche panel, than in some recent series. He has a fantastic sense of, scope and Mise-en-scène. No panel is just there to attach the dialog bubble to. You get your money’s worth out of every page.

This masterpiece is not for the faint of heart, Roche had developed a positive gift for mechanical evisceration, dismemberment, and terminal rupture. This is what that neighbor kid in “Toy Story” did to his Transformers.

Issue 5’s definition as the Climax of this series is more than just due to the place it occupies chronologically, it’s also the best issue. Even if you’re waiting for the trade, run out and pick this one up, you’ll be proud to have it in your collection. Plus it’s got THREE awesome character profiles that we’re told will not appear in the trade!

This series has come together perfectly. It’s practically flawless. In fact, a moment spent actively attempting to contrive a flaw just now met with no success. It’s not the sort of story you can tell every week. What Wreckers is, is a superbly constructed tragedy. It’s a comic book about giant robots fighting that still conveys human truth, about war and death, futility and hope, about making the wrong decisions, and learning.

Yes, I’m still talking about the comic book.

If Kurosowa made a Transformers Movie, this would be it.

Roche and Roberts have created a work that is nothing short of genius. More than once, I have had my distaste for the lesser elements of Transformers fiction challenged by the ludicrous question, “Well, what do you want from the Transformers? Shakespeare?” Of course not, that’s silly.

I want Nick Roche and James Roberts. I want the Wreckers.

Writer: James Roberts & Nick Roche
Pencils: Nick Roche & Guido Guildi
Publisher: IDW
Cover price: $3.99
On sale: Now


Images 1 to 7 of 7
More IDW Reviews
  Review: G.I.Joe #19
review by Jay Cochran
  Jun 15
2010
IDW
  Review: Transformers Ironhide #2
review by Ender
  Jun 02
2010
IDW
  Review: G.I.Joe: Origins #16
review by Jay Cochran
  Jun 01
2010
IDW
  Review: G.I.Joe Hearts And Minds #1
review by Jay Cochran
  May 25
2010
IDW
  Review: Transformers: Last Stand of the Wreckers #5
review by Ender
  May 20
2010
IDW
  Review: G.I.Joe #18
review by Jay Cochran
  May 18
2010
IDW
  Review - Transformers: Nafarious #3
review by Ender
  May 04
2010
IDW
  Review - G.I. Joe: Origins #15
review by Jay Cochran
  May 04
2010
IDW
  Review: Transformers Last Stand of the Wreckers #4
review by Ender
  Apr 20
2010
IDW
  Review: Transformers Spotlight: Prowl
review by Ender
  Apr 20
2010
IDW
CATEGORIES
next review >
< prev review

SPONSORS
ENI
About
Entertainment News International (ENI) is the popular culture network for fans all around the world. Get the scoop on all the popular comics, games, movies, toys, and more every day!
Sites
Action Figures
Comics
Classifieds
Entertainment
 
Marvel
Podcasts
Star Wars
Transformers
Links
Support
This site and content are copyright © 2013 Entertainment News International - All other rights revert to their lawful owners
This website is provided for the general public as an information and entertainment resource. If you feel this site has infringed on your legal rights, please contact us